Acids, bases and carbonates
Moderators: richardh08, Boophoenix, Lloyd
- richardh08
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2229
- Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 1:54 pm
- Location: Bedfordshire
Acids, bases and carbonates
Prompted by a recent discussion on the topic, I've written this: http://www.pyrobin.com/files/Acids%20and%20bases.pdf
My intention is that it should be interesting, regardless of anyone's level of knowledge of chemistry. No doubt you will let me know whether I have succeeded or failed!
Written by a physicist, to whom chemistry is just a side-branch of reality
My intention is that it should be interesting, regardless of anyone's level of knowledge of chemistry. No doubt you will let me know whether I have succeeded or failed!
Written by a physicist, to whom chemistry is just a side-branch of reality
Even when I'm wrong, I'm convincing.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Fascinating I got a third of the way through and thought turn the TV off and study the file with no distractions! Later, one thing I would say is sign it and add copyright to pyro-gear.co.uk, outstanding piece of work Richard.
I will be going through the whole file later as I expect some others will be.
I will be going through the whole file later as I expect some others will be.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Thank you very much Richard. I struggled a little and had to re-read some parts, but that made a good deal of sense. I could have done with a teacher like you when I was at school. Chemistry always fascinated me, but somehow, it never 'clicked'. My persistent feeling since then has been that this was down to the teaching...
One question - is OH- called a hydroxyl ion?
P.s. I believe I spotted a minor error (don't forget that I'm a technical writer/editor by trade!). I think you have an H+ missing from this paragraph:
"All carbonates, whether soluble or not, are attacked by acids. For example , if you mix a solution of sodium carbonate with dilute hydrochloric acid, you get a mixture of Na+, CO3
--, H+ and Cl- ions. Since carbonic acid is weak, some of the [H+] will combine with the CO3
-- ions to form un-dissociated carbonic acid:"
Thanks again, this article was very helpful of you.
One question - is OH- called a hydroxyl ion?
P.s. I believe I spotted a minor error (don't forget that I'm a technical writer/editor by trade!). I think you have an H+ missing from this paragraph:
"All carbonates, whether soluble or not, are attacked by acids. For example , if you mix a solution of sodium carbonate with dilute hydrochloric acid, you get a mixture of Na+, CO3
--, H+ and Cl- ions. Since carbonic acid is weak, some of the [H+] will combine with the CO3
-- ions to form un-dissociated carbonic acid:"
Thanks again, this article was very helpful of you.
"If you don't learn anything, what's the point?"
- richardh08
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2229
- Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 1:54 pm
- Location: Bedfordshire
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Yes, Tyvole, it's a hydroxyl ion. And well done for spotting the deliberate (not!) typo. It's funny how long you can stare at a piece of text and not see the obvious - especially when you have written it yourself; you know what it says!
School chemistry teachers - mine was good but boring. Everything is black and white at that level; bonds are either covalent or ionic, whereas in reality there is a gradation from one extreme to the other. My approach is to try and understand the mechanisms that make things happen the way they do. I hope some of that rubs off on others.
The one thing I'm not entirely happy with is, funnily enough, one of the discussion points that prompted me to start writing this article, and that is the role of boric acid in pyro mixtures. I started out by saying it was pointless to add boric acid to any mix containing carbonates but then I had doubts and tried it out. Boric acid does release CO2 when mixed with sodium carbonate solution, but the reaction is slow and you have to look quite hard to see the tiny stream of bubbles. I then tried it with strontium carbonate and found that this reaction is veeeery slow. Heating the water to hand-hot speeded things up a bit, but it's nothing like as violent as I had originally assumed. Hence my toned-down text.
Boric acid is a very weak acid. I measured the pH of a saturated solution this morning and it turned out to be around 5.5. Bear in mind that the acid in your stomach has a pH of about 1 or 2.
I'll be applying a few tweaks to the document later today, in response to the comments I have received.
School chemistry teachers - mine was good but boring. Everything is black and white at that level; bonds are either covalent or ionic, whereas in reality there is a gradation from one extreme to the other. My approach is to try and understand the mechanisms that make things happen the way they do. I hope some of that rubs off on others.
The one thing I'm not entirely happy with is, funnily enough, one of the discussion points that prompted me to start writing this article, and that is the role of boric acid in pyro mixtures. I started out by saying it was pointless to add boric acid to any mix containing carbonates but then I had doubts and tried it out. Boric acid does release CO2 when mixed with sodium carbonate solution, but the reaction is slow and you have to look quite hard to see the tiny stream of bubbles. I then tried it with strontium carbonate and found that this reaction is veeeery slow. Heating the water to hand-hot speeded things up a bit, but it's nothing like as violent as I had originally assumed. Hence my toned-down text.
Boric acid is a very weak acid. I measured the pH of a saturated solution this morning and it turned out to be around 5.5. Bear in mind that the acid in your stomach has a pH of about 1 or 2.
I'll be applying a few tweaks to the document later today, in response to the comments I have received.
Even when I'm wrong, I'm convincing.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Well written,easy to understand.
Thank you for this info.
Thank you for this info.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Will definitely give it the concentration it deserves when I get a chance. My experience of Chemistry was extremely similar to Tyvoles; Extremely interested in it... but not the person teaching it.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
My chemistry teacher was I complete Nutter extremely interested in pay back, IE 10 number 6 would get you the information you needed and chemicals, quinidine nitrate being a favourite of mine at the time, he was a hippy type very sarcastic stunk of cigarettes or other controlled substances but a fantastic individual , I remember one time in registration he approached me asking for a pack of cigarettes I asked why and his response was you have 8 black marks this month for non-attendance, the packet was handed over! And a mix of potassium permanganate and ammonia was left on his black board duster for the morning.Aardvark wrote:Will definitely give it the concentration it deserves when I get a chance. My experience of Chemistry was extremely similar to Tyvoles; Extremely interested in it... but not the person teaching it.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Now that's teaching!!! Where have they all gone... I fear that I've grown up (not quite) in a very boring time.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
"Written by a physicist, to whom chemistry is just a side-branch of reality"
Excellent, perhaps you could take a look at this growth on my knee! It's nice to have a GP on the page.
Chemistry - that's nice, but it isn't Physics.....
Excellent, perhaps you could take a look at this growth on my knee! It's nice to have a GP on the page.
Chemistry - that's nice, but it isn't Physics.....
All wretch and no vomit.......
- richardh08
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2229
- Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 1:54 pm
- Location: Bedfordshire
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
But everything is physics so, logically, that must include chemistry
Even when I'm wrong, I'm convincing.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Yes, you are right, EVERYTHING is physics, chemistry is cute, biology is fun and computing is easy.
Law is written down already. Engineering is physics, so they just need to be grateful. Being a Doctor of medicine is Biology, which relies on chemistry, which only happens because of the physics that do not falter in the way a molecule might.
Except for mathematics, the realm of the gods, who don't exist and are conjured up to solve problems in a way that wouldn't have occurred without physics for humans to exist and invent them as an explanation, prior to physics, where the numbers mean something, which keeps the mathematicians in a job. Prior to physics maths did not occur.
What discipline is pure without physics?
Law is written down already. Engineering is physics, so they just need to be grateful. Being a Doctor of medicine is Biology, which relies on chemistry, which only happens because of the physics that do not falter in the way a molecule might.
Except for mathematics, the realm of the gods, who don't exist and are conjured up to solve problems in a way that wouldn't have occurred without physics for humans to exist and invent them as an explanation, prior to physics, where the numbers mean something, which keeps the mathematicians in a job. Prior to physics maths did not occur.
What discipline is pure without physics?
All wretch and no vomit.......
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Catfish noodling, maybe? Nah, even that probably depends on water temperature, flow rate...
"If you don't learn anything, what's the point?"
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
The basic principle of Physics:
1. Does it or doesn't it?
2. Why?
3. What can I do to predict an outcome?
4. Was I right?
5. If inkey$=n goto 1; If inkey$=y then print 'Collect Nobel Prize' then goto 1.
1. Does it or doesn't it?
2. Why?
3. What can I do to predict an outcome?
4. Was I right?
5. If inkey$=n goto 1; If inkey$=y then print 'Collect Nobel Prize' then goto 1.
All wretch and no vomit.......
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
"inkey$"?
Showing your basic age there buddy!
Showing your basic age there buddy!
"If you don't learn anything, what's the point?"
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Or possibly an increase in estragon levels!
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Hmm looking up the thread I've never come across KMnO4 + NH3OH - my teachers let me down on that one. They were concentrating on another strong coloured substance I guess!
- richardh08
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2229
- Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 1:54 pm
- Location: Bedfordshire
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Ken and I have chatted about this. It wasn't KMnO4coalman wrote:Hmm looking up the thread I've never come across KMnO4 + NH3OH - my teachers let me down on that one. They were concentrating on another strong coloured substance I guess!
Even when I'm wrong, I'm convincing.
Re: Acids, bases and carbonates
Interestingly ammonium permanganate does appear to be friction sensitive but can't be made that way. Not would I make it - it looks a bit dodgy.